Saturday, March 17, 2007

We , the MIGRANTS : Sanjay Nirupam ( Bihar)


Once again the concept of Indianness is in danger. Raj Thackeray, small fry in Maharashtra politics, has threatened Biharis living in Maharashtra. This is exactly what Balasaheb Thackeray has been doing for the last 40 years to promote his brand of politics: “Maharashtra for Maharashtrians”. Once upon a time the target of this hatred were the South Indians, later the focus was on UP-ites, and the latest target are Biharis. During the formation of the state of Maharashtra, a similar divide was created between Maharashtrians and Gujaratis. Earlier it was the senior Thackeray, now it’s his nephew who is positioning himself as the new face of Marathi chauvinism.
The fact of the matter is that in the last four decades South Indians have not left Mumbai nor have UP-ites gone back to Jaunpur. Similarly, nobody can force Biharis to go back to their place of origin because there is a constitutional guarantee in our country, whereby every citizen is allowed to stay and earn his livelihood in any part of India. It is the law of the land that allows Biharis to live in Mumbai; Marwaris have nursed Calcutta for decades, Bengalis are living as local inhabitants in Bihar, Maharashtrians in Madhya Pradesh and South Indians in Delhi. This trend has been going on for centuries.
Economic compulsions have created a new class of ‘migrants’. They are found all over the country with no common language or birthplace, with different customs and traditions and in different professions. These migrants are uprooted from their place of origin and are regarded as ‘outsiders’ in the cities they have chosen to earn their livelihood. Is the political class in our country ready to address the fact that in this federal structure, Indians are being branded as outsiders in their own country? The government has been busy for the last several years wooing 20 million NRIs by celebrating the ‘Pravasi Divas’ every year and providing them innumerable facilities. Yet, nobody listens to the woes of the migrant class in the country. This class cuts across different communities — Gujaratis, Marwaris, Punjabis, South Indians, North Indians and of course Maharashtrians — but all of them have a common plight: Animosity directed at them by the local populace.
There are 45 lakh North Indian migrants in Mumbai and 3 crore Bihari migrants living outside Bihar globally. I am one of them. I am despised as a “bhaiyya” in Mumbai and “harry” in Delhi. Bengalis are called “bongs” in Delhi and Tamilians are “tambrahm” in Delhi. Marathis are called “kadhibhaat” in the Malwa region of Madhya Pradesh. South Indians are dubbed “annas” in Mumbai and Keralites are called “mallus” with the same contempt. Is this not chauvinism? ULFA in Assam gave an ultimatum to Bihari migrants to leave ‘their’ homeland. In the name of Son of Soil politics, Thackeray’s nephew threatens all Biharis living in Mumbai. Is this not a chauvinist remark against a linguistic community? In this TRP-driven TV market era, one actress from our country was subjected to racist taunts by a small-time British actress in a British TV show; the whole world was up in arms and the government of India activated the diplomatic mission in UK to register its official protest. It was a commendable effort in the interest of the nation. My anguish is, why was the anti-Bihari statement of Thackeray’s nephew condemned only by Lalu Prasad Yadav, Nitish Kumar and myself and few other Bihari leaders despite the fact that such statements are a threat to our national integration? Is it an issue pertaining only to Biharis?
People accuse me of politicking on this issue. But the fact is that I am deeply concerned about the national perspective and especially so, as a migrant. The victims of this sense of insecurity are spread all over the country. If this scenario continues, what will happen to the federal structure of the country? Don’t we need to open our eyes and have a national debate on the plight of migrants in our country?
I don’t know if we should leave the migrant issue to the respective state governments or enact a new federal law. There are 60 Lok Sabha constituencies where migrants are a deciding factor. There are over a hundred cities besides the main metropolitan centres where migrants are settled on a large scale. For example, Pune, Nasik, Nagpur, Ahmedabad, Surat, Baroda, Raipur, Bhopal, Gwalior, Mathura, Banaras, Coimbatore, Hyderabad, Ludhiana, Jallandhar, Chandigarh and many more. Interestingly, thousands of Kashmiri migrants are settled in Goa.
These migrants are not a burden. On the contrary, they contribute to the economic growth of the place they settle in. In Mumbai, 48 daily essential services are provided by the North Indian migrants. Ninety per cent of the restaurants in Mumbai are run by South Indians. The diamond market and the stock exchange is dominated by Gujaratis. Punjab has been the flag bearer of the green revolution and today most of the workers in the farmlands are from Bihar. Recently I visited Mundra, a huge private port in Kutch where all the daily wage labourers are from Bihar and Eastern UP. Centuries ago people from the Kutch region migrated to places all over the world in search of livelihood and today the Biharis and Eastern UP-ites are filling up the lack of labourers in the Kutch region. Do the Kutchis hate the migrants? They don’t. The nursing profession all over the country is dominated by Keralites. In Bihar the trading sector is controlled by Marwaris. In Calcutta all the rickshaw pullers are from Bihar or Eastern UP.
Migration is need based and that is on account of mutual compulsions. Let us recognise this new migrant class as a part of our social system and national structure. Else, it will fracture the social fabric in the times ahead.
The writer is spokesperson for Maharashtra Pradesh Congress Committee

9 comments:

rohit said...

I agree with Sanjay ji, in our motherland everyone has right to from one part of Mother INdia to other parts of my Mother India. Come on my Indian brothers dont allow anyone to raise such questions, its our duty help our brothers who come for earning a living

Anonymous said...

if we are migrants then what about gaikwads of vadodara gujrat, holkars of indore and scindias of gwalior, if they are ruling those regions besides not being the son of the land. "sarhad par marnewala har veer tha bharatwasi" they never refused to fight for their motherland, they never thought that why should i fight from rajasthan border or punjab border etc they may be sikh, gurkha, madrasi,etc. recently raj commented about latur earthquakes my question is which maharastrian came forward to help for any national crisis. i can give you some name who are not maharatrians still they have helped latur i think we should name 'thackeray city' and not mumbai.

Mamta Swaroop Sharan said...

Very well said!

Do take out time to read my thoughts on this at my blog:

हमारी त्रासदी - सिंगुर, मराठी मानुस और अनचाहे मेहमान

Mamta

Unknown said...

SAVE MUMBAI !!
Most migrants from outside Maharashtra are from
UP—one out of every five migrant.
* Median age of migrant is approximately 20 years.
Mumbai's population = 1.5 Crores
Marathi Population = 18 Lakh
UP Migrants population = 30 lakh
Bihari Migrants population = 16 lakh
These are the findings of a survey conducted by the International Institute of
Population Studies (IIPS) Mumbai about the trends of migration of people to Mumbai.

the highest percentage of migrants reported by Uttar Pradesh (24.3 percent)
Followed by Bihar (18.7 percent)
“The most noticeable change of migrants to Mumbai over the last fifty years, has been observed from UP, which shows an increase from 2 percent to 24 per cent and Bihar from 0.4 percent to 18 percent.”

Every day, 550 million gallons of drinking water must be brought to Mumbai from a distance of over 100 miles.
Two million people live with no toilet facilities.

Forty per cent of the formal sector jobs in Mumbai are concentrated within a two-mile radius of Flora Fountain around the Fort. There are 144 jobs for every 100 residents in the Fort area, creating enormous congestion.

Today there are over 15 million peoples. The price of land equals that of New York or Tokyo. And Mumbai has a population density of more than 17,000 people per square kilometre. (The figure for London is around 1,200.)

Each day, despite large amounts of recycling, Mumbai produces 5,000 tonnes of garbage.

Prices of foodgrains rose between June 1991 and December 1994 by 58.2%, pulses by 59.2%, textiles 42.5%, wood products by 169.4%, drugs and medicines by 41.9% and electricity by 93.4%.

Unknown said...

why my previuos comments are not approved yet Mr. nirupam,
I have many more eye openers for you.accept the facts & be gentlemen towards the communities instead of taking care of your personal interests

Anonymous said...

HAVE GUTS TO KEEP THIS MESSAGE POSTED AS IT IS .... OR WANT TO REMAIN BIHARI.... YOU CALLED FOR BRAIN STORMING IN YOUR ARTICLE NOW BRAIN STORM.... LETS SEE HOW YOU BIHARI'S TAKE THE NAKED FACT WHEN SHOWN TO YOU... THOUGH YOU ARE NOT CAPABLE OF DOING IT YOURSELF.....

DONT SKIRT OR SWEEP BENEATH THE CARPET....

Hi Dear,


It seems your CM is just busy with skirting all the issues, be it development of state, protecting Bihari’s in / out side the state..... Except one exercise and that is- 1. To appease the real saffron brigade so that they do not bad mouth him as is case with our Mr. Ex CM. 2. False / Baseless propaganda of developing the state without any ground reality. All this will lead you know where and you shall in coming days will go worst than your better noire, as he is charismatic and can shine anywhere. What about you. Pull up your shock and sleeve or kindly leave the seat.

Why Bihari's are laughed; hated & disgusted?
"Bihari's get beaten up like dogs in other house and ran as cat........ Then at home they torch their own house and like to call themselves as Lion"- when all such things are going on their Mr. CM is defenseless and hides his helpless in name of India/ Country / Integrity and what not bullshit....... its height of political daridraness….. But what one could expect from a backward kurmi who till date could not even raise his head in front of the Bhumiars; Brahman; Kayasth in their own state.
At least man should have self respect that he is a CM of state whose citizens are always and everywhere are insulted, his primary duty is to be Bihari CM but no.... oh sorry he is Bihari....... he will always talk of India .. i.e. nothing but he wants to be PM as all Bihari’s want....... ha ha ha ha ha 
Bihari's and Bihar
Will humbly do;
1. Support BJP party though Atal Bihari Vajpayee publicly as PM of India insults Bihari.
• For any other state can anybody dare.... hahaha?
• AP High Court judges commented derogatory ref of Bihar during in case where there Bihar or Bihari had nothing to do with it.
• Union Health Minister A Ramadoss has abused Bihar and Bihari’s without any reason by saying “…that a doctor from Bihar was the reason why UK derecognized Indian Medical Degrees in 1970” .
• In J&K- BSF instructors in Jammu and Kashmir harasses 136 recruits of Bihar Military Police (BMP), who later deserted the centre.
• Congress Delhi CM Sheila Dixit a Punjabi who started her career as politician from UP but could not succeed now in Delhi bashes Bihari & UPites as she knows the society is been ruled by a microscopic upper caste with such iron hand of atrocities since ages that no two caste from upper or backward can talk in same voice forget whole society.
• GOA home minister Ravi Naik opposed the introduction of train from Patna to Panaji by saying in media publicly “beggars from Bihar will start reaching the coastal states.”
• Lt Governor of Delhi too echoed the same publicly.
• Recently those who went for training for BMP (Bihar Military Police) were subjected harassment because of them being Bihari.
• Modi too said the same thing, that Bihari are not wanted.
• Late Senior BJP leader from Maharashtra Pramod Mahajan too threatened & warned Bihari student’s way back in 2005.
• Bal Thackeray & Raj Thackeray.
• Congress Home Minister RR Patil said bullet for bullet response by Mumbai police is correct for Bihari’s.
• Shatrughan the Kayasth went further denigrating Bihar & Bihari during the Marathi vs Bihari stir in Mumbai and publically called that he endorses what Bal Thackeray said and he is God for him / Bihari.
2. Bihari Bismillah Khan was not accorded the respect in AP for being Bihari; that too after receiving the highest civilian award..........hahaha 
Even though repeatedly, he requested through media for playing Shenahi in his birthplace but to vain.
Not a single time did the Govt of Bihar or any independent social body, public helped him in conducting the concert at his home place Bhagalpur and nearby village? Can such thing happen in any other state, forget government public will throng and accord all respect to their son’s/daughters.
3. Former Indian Skipper Azharuddin said all Bihari are chor’s (Thief’s) and apologized only when defamation suit was filed.
4. Bihari "JHAKI" many times have not been given permission in Delhi on republic Day........... Hahaha
5. Bihari's get insulted, harmed, killed in Punjab, J&K, Assam, Bengal, AP, Maharashtra, Delhi, Gujarat etc........ who cares.
6. …. Others they may worship the Bihari God as others want.... That is they can be selective / choosey but always slaps the same god when need be to send the message that even Bihari gods have to be in their limit........ Example "chhat ka natak", Karunanidhi "telling all sort of derogative things to God” 
7. Let everyone take the entire mineral from this land at the same rate even when transported to any part of India - without giving any benefit to the Bihar, so that other state can develop and their own masses can perish off course in name of  "India". Bottom line if Bihar starts developing then Bhumiars, Brahmans and lalla’s will lose out…. How can / dare shudra, dalits progress.
8. See Bihari’s the days are very near when others will take away the water and we will find no har har gange in our land- offcourse in name of "holy Ganga", "India", "Hinduism" etc -- and saving the Bihari’s from flood  ............ just one has to give the "Jhunjhuna" to our backward kurmi politician that you be made PM....... hahaha …… and for the murderer Bhumiars & other upper caste that whatever they do in Bihar no one would question you all………… hahaha
9. In Punjab Bihari migrant are harassed, insulted, killed enmass (by bombing theatre playing Bhojpuri film).
10. But why example of other state see Bihar whole village is wiped out from child to old human souls because they are born low caste.
11. Bihar Police lines have separate caste kitchens like “Bhumiar Chauka”, “Rajput Chauka”, “Harijan Chauka”.
12. Bhumiars caste washed the statue of their own caste man when it was garlanded by then CM Lalu Prasad Yadav and it happens by advertising in media. Forget for ordinary lower caste souls.
13. Let Bihari’s get killed in Assam & NE as they are from shudra (Still after violence the remaining who flew goes back because in Bihar it’s worse than that.)
Let Bihari’s poor girls be sold to Punjabi’s & Haryanvi’s for mere sum, primarily due to pathetic treatment they get back home as they are tribal / shudra.
Let…. Etc.
14. If any politician tries to get investment thwart it to that area on names of corruption etc and see the same is not succeeded as the downtrodden will raise their head and the hegemony of the affluent will get abolished.
I was in UP at the time of Taj Corridor- courtesy Ms Mayawati when the people started objecting I had talked with many all had to say the simple thing; she is taking bribe, pollution etc. I could not understand one thing- what’s wrong if she is taking bribe let her do after all in this commercial world who won’t take but why deny investment which will bring money to all the layers of society. The bottom line is to deny everyone the livelihood.
The whole matter was closed with help of Supreme Court on flimsy pollution ground. The whole party congress, SP, BJP etc were against it (read the people of UP) and which resulted in her to doing same thing now……… all are happy. If the same would have been in any other state one would have found the deal getting materialized. Its not politician fault, its people.

Take instance of Bihar right now;
• Has the government given any land to IIT?
• Any plan for SEZ.
• Any plan to encourage the English language in primary education so that it becomes the recruitment hub for BPO & Call Centre.
• Any plan for implementing reservation which was enshrined in constitution and based on its negotiation the independence of India was agreed upon and which has been implemented in many parts of India except in Hindi Cow Belt region.
• Any guts (political will) for land reforms with iron hand…
For all ………………………A BIG NO.
List is never ending;
Bihari's basic problem is that one cannot see or want any other Bihari should earn a decent livelihood........... And that is the reason that we all land up everywhere be it Gujarat, Maharashtra, All southern states where they have given the downtrodden opportunity to get lifted into main stream since pre independence day by reservation.......
but Bihari’s till date have circumvented always such human things to their own brethren but want themselves the benefit on the plank of "Indian".... hahaha.
All the upper / affluent caste Bihari comes to other land and work for the lower caste of that region but back in Bihar; Bihari’s are nothing but killers to their subordinate caste in socio economic hierarchy of castiest society....... 
Plssssss let look into ourselves 

P.S.

What always Bihari will say / shout at top voice; But is blind too;
Bihar is home to all religion. Religion polluted by upper caste.
All Gods are from Bihar. Bihar since long has become hell.
Most of IAS, UPSC, and many IIT, IIMs are from Bihar. Home to Ranvir Sena/Mafia/Don’s too.
All minerals & Ganga is in Bihar. Not a single industry or investment
Castiesm is in Bihar & that’s what has let us backward. Yet No land reform, no reservation etc but yes would like to be treated as Indian.
Most of them will never say / shout that I am Bihari  Will say I am born in Gujarat, Maharashtra etc 


Stop fooling yourself and bihari's in name of Inida..... India is rising and shall rise not because of bihari but rest of Indians ie people except Bihari's.

Right their is contribution a great contribution from bihari people but its true that workers do come to work...... and they get paid and their stomach filled.... and their wives & daughter gets sari, blouse, bra and panty.... plus you all can roam about peacefully 24 hours a day....

can one do same back in bihar.... forget flaunting by bihari wives & daughter of thier panty's from jeans, or bra's from cholis... even your son cannot roam freely..... how manny you bihari's visit bihar other than when someone dies, marry, etc


Southern states has not come up becoz of shiv sena hate campaign stop fooling urself and others.... but ala what one can expect from bihari....

All the reforms in western & southern states had started long ago prior to independence to include downtrodden masses in mainstream via reservation, land reform etc which gave belongingness to each other be it Gujarat, Maharashtra, Karnataka, Tamilnadu, Kerala etc (all having reservation implemented in earnest since pre independence days)....

can you Bihari do it.... bihari's are bad becoz of its upper caste who have raped their land and now try to cry foul... why bloody you want to be treated as par in regional platform.

Forget india it just came 60 yrs back.... the best would be india without poorbia and its poorbia states.....

this will result in rooten apple out as well from strategic point will be buffer from china etc

and when need be the rest of india can easily loosen the regulated visa's as per thier need...

Your ashock, mauryan all are backward caste... you moron some facts:
when the state were in hands of upper caste it got enslaved, no progress....

where the population of upper caste is more (up east, jharkhand, orissa & bihar) states/region is criminal, non progressive and fascist......

stop crying fool of indianness .... you like or not but bihar is bane to india and bihari's are dalit (poor, uneducated, communal, castiest, criminal, non-progressive etc) in regional platform....

you talk of indianness as you all are shameless & stateless thats the reason for belongingness you try to hide your pathetic biharipan in the curtain of indianness.....

rest of india is india and not you all.

i love my family and try to make them progress but that does not mean i resort into pulling others... but you bihari in name of casteism have always pulled up your own mass and states. See the anti-reservation started in bihar and your petty kurmi caste leader towed the line of upper caste pressure and the same agitation was shifted to delhi....

reseration in parliament was passed but you people did not tooked the oppurtunity ... missing the train again.... for the rest of india passing in parliament is not required and already in our states it exists......

you folks have leaders great leaders like lalu Prasad Yadav……..
but you treat leaders him by …. all bad mouthing him just bcoz he is backward and want to bring downtrodden up..... if he were from tamilnadu, gujarat etc you bihari's would have worshipped him and praised....

seee yourself all backward caste leaders in india be it Narendra Modi, Karunaniddhi, Chagan Bhujbal, etc......

and see your bihari leader kalyan singh, lalu, nitish, katiyar, uma bharti, .... hahaha

remember you all are abhored by india, you are the only state whom the sitting pm the cow eating brahman atal bihari vajpayee also kicked you in public "Bihari public"
and
of former president apj abdul kalam during the global ceo meet in patna (a public stunt/hogwash of perceived happening ala bihari lippa poti by nitish:)) ..... "bihar has to match its present with the deeds of its past glory" - means stop living in past & shed bloody bihariness...

another gujarati dignitary "Bihari politician has to change themselves" means.... bloody bihari has to change their mentality & shed their pathetic bihari pan.....

All this saying in euphemistic and directly no one will say as that would lead into numerous defamation case as you all are good in it.....

but even direct humiliation also do not have any effect on you shameless..... even your Shatrughan went to lick bal thackre and publically not only called him GOD but could not stop himself from being Bihari... and started ridiculing your ex cm Lalu Prasad Yadav..... what pathetic... but him pathetic.....its Bihari who are pathetic as he could survive behaving like this in Bihar... but why not he happen to be Kayasth... :)

can you expect anyone including GOD ridiculing any other states people he would be shunted out forever.......

even the Bihari god be it ram etc have limited in road …… god too has to get itself in our mould or starts getting thrown out in Tamilnadu... similarly with Marathi’s too... remember chhath insulting....

But for you Bihari’s this all is bull shit.... As in your brain its shit n shit and shit.

Now Bihari will be quick too point out legend and luminaries within them forgetting that it is nothing but individual excellence and not as societal achievement... as Bihari’s do not know to live in society / block.........

if Bihari politician were bad... then why outside Bihar the Bihari’s are not able to live in block.... as the case is with other state people Gujarat, Maharashtra, Punjab, Kerala, tamilians, Karnataka, Bengali, telegu etc..

see in Kerala; becoz of communist there general Keralites could not do much but see outside they know to live in blocks.... then why not Bihari .... As i said they are castiest inhuman being (human is the creature that lives in group).

Yes Bihari’s and Bihar the moment they are thrown out ... the better.

Do any wrong doing with Punjabi, tamilians, Guajarati etc and we all will raise the issue and boil it to such level that world notices and interferes then be it in India or the case of tamilians outside India like Srilanka, Singapore etc, or be it Punjabi Muslims in Pakistan... Punjabi’s will and shall always support them, or Guajarati in Africa though they are behaving and looting the local but Guajarati’s no matter where they live will raise in unison... but see you Bihari be it inside or outside India…. as the case of Bihari Muslims treated pathetically in Pakistan/Bangladesh..... No support.
The Bihari Bharat Ratna awardee… Ustad Bismillah Khan was treated badly in Hyderabad…… he’s pathetic monetary condition but no Bihari helped him out….. or he died crying that he wants to play in his birthplace…… bloody no one came to him….. if he were from other state he would have been accorded in society ….. and true to Biharipan the bihari’s would have also queued in giving him all maan and shaman. 

Only the temper can be raised (to deny their lower caste people) by the Bihari bhumihar, brahman, kayastha, like they did it anti reservation, or in name of hindu religion ... the bottom line is to deny our own brethren the lower caste rise and upliftment on all flimsy ground... of meritocracy etc and bloody what not......

SUDHARJAO NAHI TO WOH DIN DUR NAHI JAB BIHARI BASHING WILL LEAD INTO CALL FOR BIHARI HATAO A UNQUINE CASE INITSELF WHEERE THE COUNTRY COMES AND THROWS THE PORTION OF ITSELF OUTSIDE THIER NATION... :)HAHAHA....

Unknown said...

The main question still remain unanswered. Why Rikshwapuller of UP and Bihar has to go to Maharastra to earn livlihood? What the hell government of UP and Bihar has been doing for 62 years? Why there are less industires in these states? Why there are so much poverty in these state? Is it not the job of UP and Bihar government to provide enployment to their people? No one is accountable of it.

Unknown said...

Biharis give births to thousands of children everyday to distribute them to other states.Same about UP. separate these two states from India.

AZAD said...

mandbudhi akshay,

there are more farmer death in maharashtra then in up and bihar combined.

up does not only gives birth to childeren but also 2 PMs.
startling fact out of 14 PMs up has given 8 .

your cm be it deshmkh or chavan bows down their head iin front of sonia and rahul gandhi who contest elections frm up.
these are only few glaring exmpls to shut the morons like you.

so do not be astonished and recognise the nevrending power of up and bihar.